|
City’s Latest Dips into
TIF Funds for Millennium Park Cause for Concern
Although it started out as a $150 million project to be opened by 2000, Millennium
Park’s current public budget of Millennium Park is $370 million and its
completion date is scheduled to be December, 2003. This does not include the
millions that have come in from corporate and private donations to fund selected
features in the Park.
Neighborhood Capital Budget Group (NCBG) is concerned that diverting Central
Loop TIF funds to Millennium Park seriously reduces the potential amount of
surplus money that will be in the fund when it expires in 2007. After taking
$35 million from the Central Loop TIF fund in May, 2000, the City of Chicago
is now dipping even further into what is now a dwindling redevelopment fund.
Some $95 million from the Central Loop TIF fund has been allocated for Millennium
Park, according to the latest Capital Improvement Plan of the City, which covers
the years 2002-2006.*
When a TIF expires, the City is obligated to disperse the surplus to the taxing
bodies – such as Chicago Public Schools, the Chicago Park District, and
Cook County– whose property tax revenues have been frozen during the life
of the TIF. This surplus could mean a great deal to Chicago’s neighborhood
schools and parks, not to mention potentially reduced property taxes. It is
difficult to see it depleted for a project like Millennium Park, which is so
downtown-oriented. The irony here is that the law allowing the use of TIF funds
for non-TIF projects across rights of way was partly intended to help overburdened
schools near TIFs where additional population was growing.
With Millennium Park just across Michigan Avenue from the Central Loop TIF’s
eastern boundary, the fund grab is legal, but is it wise and is it fair to Chicago’s
residents?
The Central Loop TIF fund currently has a $184 million balance (according to
the City’s recently released TIF Annual Report for 2001). This is down
from the $238 million in the fund in 2000. Estimates of future tax increment,
to be deposited in the fund from now until 2007, range from $15 to $30 million
a year, depending on assessed values of properties. These funds are to be used
to leverage development within the TIF district, including the City’s
plan to buy back Block 37 property from developers and begin the development
process on the block again.
City Hall must be open and clear about capital funding programs and should
create procedural and policy reforms to head off future cost overruns. Particularly
for projects like Millennium Park, which are targeted toward Chicago’s
tourism industry, the City must seriously consider expanding its funding resources
to include use of McCormick Place and Exposition Authority resources.
The Mayor’s Capital Improvement Advisory Council
should take a close look at such overruns, especially
ones as dire as Millennium Park’s.
* NOTE: In a further drain on Central
Loop TIF resources, in early May, 2002, the Chicago
City Council approved a $160 million general obligation
bond issue that would be retired with property taxes
derived from the Central Loop TIF after it expires.
If the City issues this bond, the benefit of the Central
Loop TIF’s growth in property value –
and hence tax revenue -- will be tied up and unavailable
to schools, parks, and other taxing bodies, which
will have waited 23 years to get the TIF windfall.
The bond proceeds may indeed be used for legitimate
capital expenditures, but given the public’s
limited impact on this and other TIF spending and
financing decisions, how the City will actually use
these funds is unclear. As the Chicago Tribune pointed
out in a June 14, 2002 editorial, “… the
ordinance is vague enough to allow spending some of
the money on routine, everday expenses and on contributions
to the city’s pension
|